NickFerris's Lists

Captain Benjamin Sisko

Far Beyond the Cards

deck

Captain Benjamin Sisko

Nov 18, 2026

I got back into Magic a few months ago for the first time in 31 years thanks to the announcement of the Star Trek set. I've absolutely loved the set and have been building all sorts of silly Commander decks featuring my favorite characters at the helm. But my favorite deck so far, both thematically and in demonstrated effectiveness, puts Captain Benjamin Sisko in command and gives him an absolutely legendary crew. The deck takes full advantage of both sides of his design: leveraging his dilemma-driven go-wide trigger while building around his WUBRG activated ability with a deliberately diverse mix of lands and creatures, bringing together all sorts of Federation and Strange New Worlds synergies. As a lifelong Trekkie, what I love most is how naturally the deck embodies one of Star Trek's most important ideals: that diversity isn't just something to celebrate, it's a source of strength. Sisko's design actually rewards players for embracing that diversity, making the deck feel like a celebration of the Federation itself. ////////////////////// A few design notes: ////////////////////// 1. I kept the entire deck in Star Trek because I really wanted to showcase what this set can do, though I would've loved to throw in a few dilemmas from elsewhere (why no Black Market Connections reprint???). ////////////////////// 2. No starships in a Star Trek deck? No DS9 in a Sisko deck? I had those, but the deck's performed far more consistently since I pulled them all in favor of more officers or varied creature types. ////////////////////// 3. If this deck has one big weakness, it's that I feel compelled to narrate its deep theming to every non-Trekkie at the table, and then I get into a tangent into potential entry points to watching the series...