Star Trek Precon - the Caretaker
deck The Caretaker
Nov 14, 2026
The Caretaker is a Dilemma deck, one focused on playing the top non-land cards of an opponent's deck blindly. Thematically, kidnapping ships from across the galaxy, the opener to Star Trek: Voyager. The deck runs 28 such cards to activate the commander. The deck is packed with plenty more Star Trek cards, including some very light support for the Strange New Worlds mechanic in a few creatures (thus the high non-Island land count).
While any Dilemma deck can work well, in practice there are entirely too many cards to narrow down, thus sticking to one color (and colorless). In Blue, many of those cards can either counter a spell or draw cards, so the cards retain some synergy. Some artifacts also contribute to the potential list as well.
The deck may struggle to close a game. Most of the creatures are there for utility, not their body size. Options include (a) making a legendary creature exceptionally large, (b) boosting the size of all creature of a given color (blue) via Anthem effects; or (c) copying and theft effects. The issue is finding room for these while retaining critical mass to activate the commander.